Sign Up for our Free Daily Email Updates / Catholic Spiritual Direction

Gospel Truth in Fiction

February 7, 2017 by  
Filed under Book Club, Sarah Reinhard

Book Club INTERNAL IMAGE (internal to post) 600x214 for post on Seeds of the Word

Gospel Truth in Fiction

Seeds of the Word (Week 6 of 11)

I'm a huge fan of novels. Left to my own devices, I might never pick up another nonfiction book…

And when I have the chance to find the Gospel truth in fiction…well, I feel more than a little justified. 🙂

Last year, I pulled a novel off the shelf. “I advise to read it,” the cover boasted, with Pope Francis' name underneath.

I dove in, skipping the (probably very interesting and educational) introduction by Fr. Mark Bosco, S.J. I had no idea what the book was about, aside from the back cover's claim that it's “one of the first dystopian novels of the twentieth century.”

When I realized that this book was published in 1907, long before the current thread of dystopian reading was even dreamed, I was taken aback. Bishop Barron writes,

…like any apocalypse, this one is a bit exaggerated and melodramatic; nevertheless, there are a lot of lessons for us in it. It is truly impressive that, in 1907, Benson saw, as clearly as he did, the dangerous potential of the secularist ideology. By this I mean the view that this world, perfected and rendered convenient by technology, would ultimately satisfy the deepest longing of the human heart. One of the most elemental truths that the Catholic Church preserves is that human beings have been created by and for God and that they will therefore be permanently dissatisfied with anything less than God.

Turning from one end to the other in today's reading, Barron reminded me of the delight of The Hobbit. My husband and I went to see the three movies, and though I sputtered (as I often do) about how butchered the screenplay was compared to the book's brilliance, we were mostly glad to see Middle Earth brought to life again.

But to enter Middle Earth, truly, one should enter between the covers of Tolkien's book (or through one of the great audiobook renditions). Don't go for abridged: you deserve it all. Trust me.

How, though, is the adventures of Bilbo Baggins true to the Gospel of Jesus Christ? Barron is particularly insightful:

What is particularly instructive in The Hobbit is the manner in which a Christian knight properly engages in the battle. At a key moment in the story, Gandalf suggests that while many think darkness is best opposed through exercises of great worldly power, in point of fact, it is most effectively countered through simple acts of kindness. This is, of course, nothing but Jesus' still deeply challenging teaching in the Sermon on the Mount that evil is properly resisted through love, nonviolence, and forgiveness.

I have plenty of other books to read, but I can't help but feel a revisit to one or both of these classics is in order, especially after Barron's thoughts!

Reading Assignment:

Why Faith…?Why Anti-Catholic

Discussion Questions:

1. Have you read either of these novels? What struck you in Barron's insights about them and your own experience reading them?

2. Of the other books covered in this reading, what did you find most intriguing or promising as a potential read?

Feel free to comment on anything from our assignment this past week!

Read More:

For More Information on the Book Club:

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

About Sarah Reinhard

Sarah Reinhard continues to delight ”and be challenged by” her vocations of Catholic wife and mother. She's online at and is the author of a number of books for families.

please consider supporting our mission with a donation!